Each paragraph within the body with this perceptive essay identifies and examines an unstated presumption that is essential to the argument.

Each paragraph within the body with this perceptive essay identifies and examines an unstated presumption that is essential to the argument.

Rater Commentary for Essay Response — Score 5

The major assumptions talked about are:

  • that a survey can predict behavior accurately
  • that cleansing the river will, by itself, enhance leisure usage
  • that state plans to completely clean the river will really be realized
  • that Mason City are able to pay more on riverside recreational facilities

Help within each paragraph is actually thoughtful and thorough. As an example, paragraph 2 points out vagueness within the wording for the study: Regardless of if water sports ranking among the list of favorite recreational use of Mason City residents, other activities may be a great deal more popular. Hence, in the event that assumption that is first unwarranted, the argument to invest in riverside facilities — in the place of soccer areas or golf courses — becomes much weaker. Paragraph 4 considers several reasons why river clean-up plans is almost certainly not effective (the plans can be only campaign claims or money may possibly not be adequate). Thus, the weakness associated with the assumption that is third the argument that river entertainment will increase and riverside improvements will soon be required at all.

In the place of dismissing each presumption in isolation, this reaction puts them in a rational order and considers their connections. Note the transitions that are appropriate and within paragraphs, clarifying backlinks among the list of presumptions ( e.g., “Closely for this studies …” or “the solution to this concern calls for. “).

This response also displays facility with language along with strong development. Minor mistakes in punctuation can be found, but term alternatives are apt and sentences suitably diverse in length and pattern. The reaction works on the quantity of rhetorical concerns, nevertheless the implied responses are constantly clear adequate to offer the points being made. (more…)